Skip to main content

last stand on murder hill

What makes a good multiplayer shooter experience? Been playing them for years and only now do I ask myself that question in light of my recent experiences with Battlefield 4. Okay so its partly a game and partly an exercise in futile frustration in its current broken state but there's some intangibles here worth pondering I think.

Is it the guns? The maps? The looks? Is it the reflexes required to succeed? Is it the systems of points and scores? Is it the players? Is it the hidden hand of the developers as they quietly pull the strings behind the scenes and manipulate the on-screen action as it ebbs and flows from one murderfest to the next?

Having played so many online shooters over the years and having some very distinct opinions on which games were good and bad I now wonder what aspect if any separates them at all. Of course there are well made games and games that fall apart at the start and never get back up again but beyond that what makes a game undeniably good or bad online?

I ask this because ostensibly Battlefield 4 is pretty much the same game I've been playing for the last few Battlefield games, going at least as far back as the Bad Company games. Ostensibly the same, yet somehow lacking a certain something I can't quite nail down. It's probably one of those frustratingly vague combinations of all the above. A freewheeling blend of chaos where it all comes into play. A push and pull between control and the lack of it.

Making my last stand on murder hill (every hill's a murder hill in first person shooter online) earlier tonight I wondered how Battlefield 4 could essentially be the same as Bad Company 2 but somehow less engaging, less fun, less something something. Franchise fatigue maybe? Too many tweaks to a formula that wasn't broken in the first place? See how this is devolving into further questions? This definitely appears to be one of those topics. 

As such I doubt I'm going to get to the crux of the matter by the end of this entry. For all that these games are meticulously designed and stage-managed I don't think its entirely in the hands of the makers. Conversely the players who perhaps shape the experience as much as the developers do, well perhaps they wouldn't stick around were it not for all the unseen tinkering and manipulation behind the scenes? So maybe its some ambiguous sweet spot inbetween but who knows? Answer: not me!

Maybe Battlefield 4 is broken and I should leave it at that. Maybe the intangible is succinctly tangible after all? Have my doubts that it'll be as good as it used to be even when its fixed though. Why is that when on paper at least these games are nigh on identical? Okay no more questions, that's it. This is as deep as the rabbit hole that is my brain goes for now. Another proud moment for my brain there. Just doing its job, whatever that is exactly.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

anime hair and the end of days

I've just completed a game that, in normal circumstances at least, wouldn't generally be my cup of tea. A game remastered and released in 2021 but which originally arrived in 2010 in a somewhat 'adjusted' manner shall we say?. A game I meant to get around to back then but never did and now that I have finally gotten around to both playing and completing it, I'm not entirely sure if I liked it or not. That game is Nier Replicant or to give it it's full re-released title:  Nier Replicant ver.1.22474487139... because clearly the game alone wasn't baffling enough....
Post a Comment
more>>>

horror movie mania 2023

Once more we return to my favourite time of year. The air cools to a brisk chill, the leaves go red and brown in that deeply pleasing way and the evenings grow steadily darker. This year it's slightly different for me as major non-threatening life events unfolded earlier this month but amidst a flurry of recent activity I have found time to sneak in that most precious of all October past-times, the Halloween-adjacent horror movie marathon.  This year I've managed to watch more than a film or two so thought I'd give my thoughts in brief on each one. These are mostly films that have been on my to-watch list for an age with an exception or two and there may be more than one movie called Halloween as it happens, maybe even more than two. To the hot takes...
Post a Comment
more>>>

gaming archaeology

There is an art to playing old games, a   mindset even. A requisite state of mind thats required in order to play through its history. It's often said that you can't judge the past by the standards of the present and this is true to a point. Beyond that point the present can very much creep into your judgements and I think this is fine too as long as you are honest about it. The present moment can indeed cast a harsh light on the past, revered classics may not hold up even if you can still see what made them tick way back when. Such thoughts have come to mind recently as I found myself playing through the original 1987 release of Maniac Mansion .
Post a Comment
more>>>